Coat, recover or replace? A first read on your roof
Seven answers about the roof you have now. The checker applies the same rules we use on the roof: layer limits, wet insulation, deck condition and how long you plan to hold the building.

Most sensible next step
Repair and monitor
The rules the checker uses
A coating only works over a roof that is mostly dry and still attached. If a moisture survey shows more than about a quarter of the insulation is wet, coating it seals the water in and the roof keeps rotting from the inside.
A recover puts new insulation and a new membrane over the old roof. Building codes cap a roof at two coverings, so a second recover is never an option, and the old roof has to be dry enough and the deck sound enough to carry it.
A tear-off is the answer when the deck is damaged, when the insulation is soaked, or when two roofs are already in place. It costs the most up front and gives you the longest clean start, plus the insulation your energy code now asks for.
What makes the result final
The checker is a first read. These are the things we confirm on the roof before recommending anything:
- An infrared or capacitance moisture survey, verified with core cuts
- A count of existing roof layers at several cores
- Deck condition from below and at any soft spots
- Drainage: slope, crickets, drain and scupper sizes
- Edge metal and flashing heights at walls and curbs
- Warranty status and what the manufacturer allows over the existing roof
- Your budget year and how long you expect to hold the property
When the checker cannot help
Active leaks over people, power or stock come first. Call (615) 716-3057 and we deal with the water tonight; the coat, recover or replace question can wait until the roof is dry and someone has looked at it properly.
About the recover or replace checker
Is the coat, recover or replace checker accurate for my building?
It applies real rules, but it cannot see your roof. Treat it as a way to know which conversation to have. The final answer comes from a moisture survey, core cuts and a look at the deck, which we do on every recover or restoration job.
Why does the checker push me to replace when I already have two roofs?
Building codes limit a roof to two coverings. With two already on the deck, the next roof must start with a tear-off, so coating may buy a few years but a recover is not allowed.
Does a recover cost much less than a tear-off in Nashville?
Often it does, because you skip demolition and disposal and keep some of the old insulation value. The gap shrinks if wet areas have to be cut out or the deck needs repair, which is why the survey comes first.