Skip to content
KestrelCommercial Roofs · Nashville

How to compare two commercial roof bids, line by line

Two commercial roof bids can differ by thirty thousand dollars and still describe different roofs. The fix is to put both on the same page and compare what each one actually builds.

Percy LangstonFacility Roof Guides EditorUpdated

Two stacked roofing proposals on a conference table beside a cut core sample of white membrane over gray polyiso, with a Nashville downtown skyline visible through a tall office window behind.
Facility guide

The short version

Rebuild both bids into one table with the same rows: tear-off scope, insulation type, R-value and thickness, cover board, attachment method, edge metal spec, flashing details, warranty type and length, exclusions, and unit prices for wet insulation and deck repair. A lower total usually means a missing row, not a better price.

Why the lower bid is often a different roof

Contractors write proposals in their own words, in their own order, with their own assumptions. One bid says 'new TPO system.' The other says '60-mil TPO, 2 layers of 2.6 inch polyiso, half-inch cover board, fully adhered, 24-gauge edge metal.' Both are called a replacement, and they are not the same product.

The difference shows up in the total first and in the roof ten years later. A thinner insulation package, a mechanically attached membrane where an adhered one was expected or a skipped cover board all cut cost. None of them is wrong in every case. The problem is when you cannot see the cut because it was never written down.

So do not compare totals. Compare scopes. Make a single table with one column per bidder and one row per item below, then fill every cell from the paper, not from what the salesperson said in the parking lot. Where a cell is blank, call and get the answer in writing before you rank anything.

The rows every bid comparison needs

Copy these into a spreadsheet and fill them in for each proposal. Any row you cannot fill is a question for the contractor.

  • Tear-off scope: full removal to deck, partial removal or recover, and who handles disposal
  • Membrane type, thickness and color, such as 60-mil or 80-mil TPO, 0.060 inch PVC or 45-mil EPDM
  • Insulation material, number of layers, total thickness and the resulting R-value
  • Cover board type and thickness, or a clear statement that none is included
  • Attachment method: fully adhered, mechanically attached or ballasted
  • Edge metal and coping: gauge, profile, finish and whether it is built to ANSI/SPRI ES-1
  • Flashing scope: curbs, pipes, walls, scuppers, drains and the roof hatch
  • Tapered insulation or crickets, with a drawing or a note on where they go
  • Warranty type, length, who issues it and what it excludes
  • Allowances and unit prices for wet insulation, deck repair and added blocking
  • Permit, crane, dumpster, safety and temporary protection responsibilities
  • Schedule, working hours, tenant notice and how weather delays are handled

Insulation, attachment and edge metal side by side

These three rows move the price and the performance more than any others. Use the ranges as general planning figures for Middle Tennessee, since site conditions, height and access change them, and we quote after a site visit.

ItemLower-cost versionHeavier-duty version
InsulationOne layer of polyiso at 2 to 2.5 inches, about R-12 to R-15Two staggered layers at 4 to 5 inches total, about R-24 to R-30
Cover boardNone, membrane over polyiso facerHalf-inch high-density board that resists hail and foot traffic
AttachmentMechanically attached with fasteners and plates in rowsFully adhered over cover board, fewer penetrations in the deck
Edge metalLight-gauge drip edge, standard finish24-gauge or heavier coping and fascia tested to ANSI/SPRI ES-1
Typical installed range$7.60 to $10.90 per sq ft$10.45 to $15.30 per sq ft

Insulation: thickness and R-value are not the same line

Bids often state thickness, 'two inches,' and leave R-value out. Polyiso rated around R-5.7 per inch on paper loses some of that value in cold weather and over time, so a thin board and a thick board are not close. Ask for the total number of layers, the total thickness and the R-value the contractor is basing it on.

Energy codes can require added insulation when a roof is replaced, and the requirement depends on the jurisdiction. Metro Nashville Codes covers permits in Davidson County, and other counties and cities have their own offices. A bid that quietly drops below the required thickness may price lower today and fail plan review tomorrow.

Thicker insulation raises the roof edge and the height of every curb, wall flashing and door threshold. Check that each bid accounts for that. A proposal that adds four inches of foam but keeps the old flashing heights has left work out, and the change order shows up after the tear-off.

Attachment and edge metal decide wind performance

A fully adhered membrane over a cover board behaves differently in a wind event than a mechanically attached sheet with fasteners every few feet. Neither is automatically better for every building, but they cost differently and carry different warranty conditions. Make sure both bids describe the same method, or accept that you are choosing between two methods rather than two prices.

Edge metal is where wind starts lifting a roof. The perimeter takes the worst uplift, and the Middle Tennessee record of straight-line wind and tornado damage, including the March 2020 and December 2023 storms, is a good reason to read this line closely. Ask for gauge, profile, finish, cleat type and whether the system is tested to ANSI/SPRI ES-1.

A bid that says 'edge metal per manufacturer' is not a spec. The manufacturer's warranty may require a certain edge detail for a given wind speed, and the contractor should write it down. If one bid prices a heavy coping and the other prices a thin drip edge, the second one is not cheaper, it is a different roof edge.

Wet insulation allowances and unit prices for change orders

No one knows how much insulation is wet until the old membrane comes off, unless a moisture survey and cores were done first. That is why good bids include an allowance and unit prices. An allowance is a set number of square feet of insulation replacement already included in the base price. A unit price is the cost per square foot for any quantity above it.

Compare the allowance quantity first. A bid that assumes zero wet insulation will look lowest and then grow. A bid that assumes eight percent of the roof is wet, based on a survey, is more honest. Then compare unit prices. Wet insulation replacement might run $3.40 to $6.10 per sq ft and deck repair $2.85 to $5.70 per sq ft, depending on deck type, thickness and access.

Ask both contractors to price the same extras in the same units: wet insulation per sq ft, steel deck patching per sq ft or per sheet, plywood replacement per sheet, added blocking per linear foot, and crickets per each. With those numbers you can run a simple test, adding the cost of a ten percent overrun to each total and seeing whether the ranking changes.

Exclusions that quietly move the price

The exclusions paragraph is usually the shortest part of a bid and the most expensive if you skim it.

Rooftop unit lifting

Lifting and resetting HVAC units for curb work may be excluded, leaving you to hire a mechanical contractor.

Lightning protection and solar

Removing and reinstalling rooftop systems is often excluded and priced as a separate trade.

Deck repair beyond the allowance

Everything past the stated quantity becomes a change order at whatever price the contractor names then.

Interior protection

Ceiling tiles, dust barriers and tenant relocation are usually the owner's problem unless the bid says otherwise.

Permits and inspections

Some bids exclude permit fees or the cost of a third-party inspection, which can surprise a tight budget.

Warranty fees and extras

A longer warranty may carry a fee or require upgrades that were not in the base price.

Warranty type matters more than warranty length

A twenty-year label tells you little until you know what it covers.

QuestionManufacturer NDL warrantyContractor workmanship warranty
Who stands behind itThe membrane manufacturer, when the system and installer qualifyThe roofing contractor alone
What it coversMembrane and flashing defects, with limits on labor and consequential damageInstallation errors such as bad seams or flashing
Common exclusionsPonding water, storm damage, foot traffic, rooftop equipment workWeather events, other trades, lack of maintenance
What to askRead the sample document, not just the brochure, and confirm the insulation and edge metal it requiresHow long the workmanship coverage runs, and the written process for a leak call

Questions readers send us about this

Is the cheapest commercial roof bid ever the right one?

It can be, when the scopes truly match and the contractor has priced real allowances. More often a low total leaves out cover board, edge metal or wet insulation. Rebuild both bids into one table first, then compare totals. If rows match, the lower number is simply the lower number.

How many unit prices should a roof bid list for change orders?

At minimum: wet insulation per square foot, deck repair per square foot or sheet, added blocking per linear foot and tapered crickets per each. Having them in writing before the job starts caps what a surprise can cost and lets you compare contractors fairly.

Should the insulation R-value be written into the bid?

Yes. Thickness alone hides differences, and energy code requirements can apply when a roof is replaced. Ask for the number of layers, total thickness and the R-value used, then confirm the local permit office accepts it for your building before you sign.

Call 24/7 · (615) 716-3057